Last week I went to an art lecture, really more of a conversation, held uptown between Robert Storr and Arthur Danto, two esteemed art critics.
You know I like Robert Storr. I like his writings, I like his attitude, I like his hair. A friend pointed out to me that he chooses to champion some pretty dubious artists (Philip Pearlstein, Chuck Close). I don’t care—we all have our tastes and Storr’s tastes are refreshingly broad and and his writing insightful.
It turns out I also like Danto, kind of an oddball grandfather type, slightly heavyset with a white beard, gregarious and opinionated. He said that American critics whose ideas are derived from continental philosophy of the past century (basically the editors of OCTOBER) were “medieval” and had no relation to the art being produced today. Danto comes to art by way of philosophy (and he came to philosophy by way of art, coming to New York from Detroit to be an Abstract Expressionist). In regard to art, his philosophical concerns are primarily ontological—seeing the Warhol Brillo Box show in the mid-sixties was a breakthrough moment. “What makes these Brillo Boxes—which look just like the ones in the grocery store, despite being made of plywood—different from the ones in the grocery store?” he said to himself and off he went to write several books which I’ve heard are good, but haven’t read.

The high point of the evening came when Storr and Danto butted heads for ten minutes over the merits of Bruce Nauman, Storr was pro-Nauman, Danto was against. Storr gave a reasoned, detailed appeal but Danto wasn’t having it.
Here are Arthur Danto’s reasons for not liking Nauman:
1. Nauman always assumes an antagonistic relationship to his audience
2. Too noisy
3. Relies on lame jokes
4. Danto didn’t need to take that crap
I think those are pretty good reasons. I’ve never really fallen in love with Nauman, even though liking him is pretty much a prerequisite if you want to be a hip young artist. Maybe there’s a general misanthropy about his work that I don’t like, as Danto suggests.

Here are two more things I don’t really care for that everyone else seems to like:
1. stuffed grape leaves
2. Cat Power