A couple days ago a Mary Heilmann post was placed on Painters NYC, sparking a debate regarding the merits of her work, compared to that of Thomas Nozkowski. While everyone seemed to gush over Nozkowski’s work, many were turned off by Mary Heilmann’s stuff and that led me to think that there is an unsettling Cult of Nozkowski afoot in New York and beyond. Go into any art program (especially at Rutgers, where he teaches) and you’ll see tons of Nozkowski-like paintings, quirky intimate abstractions, obsessively labored, always with a few gauzy washes, always with some colorful foreground shapes.
And of course, you’d really have to be a cold-hearted bastard not too like a Nozkowski painting. Look at this one from his show now up at Max Protech:

It’s incredibly sophisticated and lovely—that soft navy wash across the background, overlapping the outside blobby shapes—terrific. And the blobby shapes themselves, each a different color, are so subtle and precious, it really takes you aback. And the size of his paintings—that un-hip “couch” size that no self-respecting artist works in—is great.
Here’s another one:

And another:

So what’s the problem? No problem really. But Nozkowski’s strengths—his gentleness, his intimacy, the endless revisions his canvases go through—are also his weaknesses. You want to say, “Jesus, Tom, stop being so lovely.” You look at the above painting and you know that he must have changed the color of those squares 87 times and it just makes you depressed. Maybe you think about yourself endlessly mixing colors, fiddling with color relationships, thinking to yourself, “God, I’m such an asshole, just put a color down and be done with it.” Nozkowski lives in this world, this world of painters obsessions; it’s why so many painters love him.
Compare that with this painting by Mary Heilmann:

Bam! This painting would punch a Nozkowski painting right in the face. It looks so effortless; it probably was effortless. And it has a really charged “dumbness” that Nozkowski would never allow. It says to you, “look, I’m a ‘geometric abstraction’—my colors are orange, red, yellow, black, green and blue.” This type of semiological approach to painting is also very un-Nozkowski and it pushes Heilmann into a conceptual realm that most painters dare not tread. And still the paintings are very arresting, gorgeous even.
Like this one.

And this.

So I’m down on painters who don’t like Heilmann. But, I’m also down on clever types who can’t find joy in Nozkowski.